jfurr,
The design is a bit confusing, but it works.
The number of stars next to a course name represent the community average, not your personal rating. When you rate a course (from either your game page or the course home page), the color changes from yellow to blue to indicate you submitted a rating. However, when you refresh the page, it changes back to yellow to represent the community average. But, if you click on the course home page after you rate a course, you'll notice under the "Reviews/Comments" that your recent rating posted.
